In modern times the four books are usually filled out by the classic of filial piety, item 9. Buddhism by robert truckle in this essay, two world religions will be compared to see how similar andor how different they are. Difference between confucianism and taoism compare the. A key point of the doctrine of the mean is the importance of a unified purpose between principle and mind, whereby one might achieve, within oneself, a manifestation of heaven. You can follow any responses to this entry through the rss 2. He taught that a ruler must set an example to inspire people to strive for a moral life. Sal gives an overview of teachings of confucius and its impact on chinese culture. Confucius lived a simple life, spending most of his time as a teacher. Chinese philosophy general the basics of philosophy. Confucianism, doaismm, mohism, and legalism flashcards. Confucianism is depending on ones perspective either a religion, philosophical movement, cultural way of life, or governmental system. From zhu xis time to our own, particular stress has been placed on the four books as the most central part of the canon, as well as the place for students to begin their lifelong study of it. Confucianism, doaismm, mohism, and legalism quizlet.
Jian ai and the mohist attack of early confucianism request pdf. Mo s principle of all embracing love amounts to making one s lather of no account. Mohism, also spelled moism, school of chinese philosophy founded by mozi q. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site. Unlike confucianism, however, daoism eventually developed into a selfconscious religion, with an organized doctrine, cultic practices, and institutional leadership.
What is the difference between daoism and confucianism. Jian ai and the mohist attack of early confucianism. As far as its core moral philosophy is concerned, neo confucianism represents a significant departure from classic confucianism. Start studying confucianism, doaismm, mohism, and legalism. The goal of writing compare and contrast essay is in analyzing the differences and or similarities between two subjects of choice if you simply point out, what is different or what is.
Mencius also spelled mengzi or mengtzu, a book of his conversations with kings of the time, is one of the four books which form the core of orthodox confucian thinking. Although it has long been forgotten in chinese history, mohism and confucianism were the two major philosophies, despite having opposing ideas. Through extensive textual evidence, it illustrates that classical confucianism, mohism and daoism contained rich notions of dignity, which laid the foundation for human rights and political. Confucianism, also known as ruism, is a system of thought and behavior originating in ancient china. Mozi pioneered the argumentative essay style and constructed the first normative and political theories. Buddhism 376 million followers tripitaka pali canon 5. Bria 24 2 c the development of confucianism in ancient china. Confucianism vs taoism difference and comparison diffen. More than the analects, the book of mencius possesses real eloquence, with. Taoism and confucianism have lived together in china for well over 2,000 years. The han dynasty that followed adopted confucianism as the official state philosophy, as did most other successive dynasties. The philosophies of early chinese civilizations including confucianism, taoism, mohism, and legalism influenced the development of these civilizations. Human dignity in classical chinese philosophy confucianism. Counter argument mohist love people just based on benefit of the world.
One of mencius selfappointed tasks was to oppose yang chu and mo ti. In part, because the doctrines of religious daoism inevitably differed from the philosophy from which. Virtue ethics and consequentialism in early chinese philosophy. Daoism confucianism and daoism, although are intermingled among people who practice them, have very different views on what is necessary to become an exemplary person. It evolved at about the same time as confucianism, taoism and legalism. This advocacy of impartiality was a target of attack by the other chinese.
Mohism springs from the teachings of mo di, or mozi. How is the teaching of mo tzumohism different from confucianism. Though buddhism continues to be the main religion of china, confucianism and taoism are two dominating philosophies in china that are very old, and continuing to be in existence since. Years after he died, students assembled his teachings into a. Unfortunately, it fell out of popularity, and more or less ceased to exist around when bc switched to ad, and so not known of by many. It is one of the three major philosophy, had the same status as confucianism even higher.
How would chinese culture be different if mohism had been. Confucianism daoism mohism legalism different and same. Although attributed to mo ti, the motzu was probably composed over a number of generations by mo tis disciples. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Confucian thought on the free economy, in the history of ancient chinese economic thought, ed. Guo 1995 its primary purpose is to achieve harmony, the most important social value. Mohism, school of chinese philosophy founded by mozi q.
They share common beliefs about man, society, and the universe, although these notions were around long before either philosophy. It has been established that none of them has been written by confucious kungtzu, 551479 b. He formulated a pragmatic theory of language that gave classical chinese philosophy its distinctive character. Role of confucianism confucianism, the teachings of confucius during 500 bc, has played an important role in forming chinese character, behavior and way of living. Being compassionate one can afford to be courageous, being frugal one can afford to extend ones territory, not daring to take the lead in the empire one can afford to be lord over the vassals.
Through extensive textual evidence, it illustrates that classical confucianism, mohism and daoism contained rich notions of dignity, which laid the foundation for human rights and political liberty in china, even though, historically, liberal democracy failed to grow out of the. They were extremely passive and believed that conflicts arose out of want of mutual love. Confucianism was a preserve of traditional values and concerned fields of ethnics and politics. Top answer different in the following ways the ten mohist doctrines as their movement developed, the mohists came to present. The motzu originally consisted of 71 chapters, but 16 of these have been lost. Fundamental difference between confucianism and mohism. Fundamental difference between confucianism, and mohism here we find the fundamental difference between confucianism and mo hism. Confucius is traditionally credited with having authored or edited many of the chinese classic texts including all of the five classics. Mozi used to disagree with confucian ideas about social. When the mohists searched the distant past for a model for the present, they discovered not confucian precedents of ritual rule, but a meritocracy that raised to power people who resisted the lure of personal enrichment and showed the ability to treat the masses of common people with. Mohism the first of these is the school of mo, mojia, created by followers of mozi, mozi. Fundamental difference between confucianism and mohism here. The first is known as compassion, the second is known as frugality, the third is known as not daring to take the lead in the empire.
Mencius interpretation of confucianism has generally been considered the orthodox version by subsequent chinese philosophers, especially the neoconfucians of the song dynasty. The shi ji, a han dynasty record, tells us only that he was an official of the state of song and that he lived either at the same time as or after confucius d. Keywords human nature confucian tradition civil religion confucian scholar shang dynasty. He was a chinese philosopher during early warring states period and the philosophy that he made was known as mohism and it is sometimes translated as universal love. In ancient china, many different rulers tried to unify and rule the country using a variety of methods confucianism, daoism, and legalism to name a few. Zhu placed this text last among the four books because, having studied the other three, the student could here study the intricacies of confucian philosophy. The doctrines of mohism are to be found in the work motzu, named after the founder of the moist tradition mo ti c. Like confucianism, mohism was a type of radical conservatism. Compare and contrast essay on taoism and confucianism. Confucianism believes in setting good examples for others to follow, primarily in 5 key relationships. Confucianism, less metaphysical in its principles, emphasizes family values and the role of the individual within the state. Neither can be considered to have approached the status of philosophical orthodoxy or dominance.
The analects by confucius, mencius by mencius, the worlds religions by huston smith, the great transformation. It was probably compiled by the second generation of confucius disciples. Confucianism is based on the thought that education, history, structure, rules and regulation will lead to achievement and becoming fully human. Daoism and confucianism arose as philosophical worldviews and ways of life. Although confucianism isnt strictly a religion, it does have a number of prominent texts, considered by many followers, to be sacred. In this context, we can discern in the schools of confucianism, taoism and legalism, three distinct vantage points. This book reinterprets classical chinese philosophical tradition along the conceptual line of human dignity. Although it has long been forgotten in chinese history, mohism and confucianism were the. The huainanzi, a han dynasty text, claims that mozi was an apostate ru confucian, but. Yet confucianism, concieved of slightly earlier in the same time, not only survived as official doctrine of the han. May 30, 2017 mohism had been one of three popular doctrine during the peirod of waring statesbc 475bc221. Taoism, and later buddhism, also played an important part in later chinese life and thought, while mohism all but disappeared as a separate school of thought.
Mohism or moism was an ancient chinese philosophy of logic, rational thought and science developed by the academic scholars who studied under the ancient chinese philosopher mozi c. They were selected by zhu xi in the song dynasty to serve as general introduction to confucian thought, and they were, in the ming and qing dynasties, made the core of the official curriculum for the civil service. What are the top ten religions and what is the holy book. Sep 17, 2010 confucius become a instructor and had fairly some awareness in his sayings. Download the bible, the holy quran, the mahabharata, and thousands of free pdf ebooks on buddhism, meditation, etc. The philosophies are confucianism, mohism and legalism. The influence of mozis philosophy, or mohism, according to my teacher and confirmed through personal research, died out during the han dynasty in 220 ad.
It was developed to bring peace and stability in society. However, the four books, are considered the closest we come to the original teaching of confucious. Chinese philosophy east asian religious texts philosophy books religion in china religious philosophical literature religious. Confucianism is a philosophy based on mutual respect and kindness toward others. What are differences between mohism from confucianism and. The main difference between confucianism and taoism is in the focus of each philosophy as confucianism focuses on the society while taoism focuses on the nature. The philosophy of confucius emphasises personal and governmental morality, correctness of social relationships, justice and sincerity, which were developed into a system known as confucianism. It evolved at about the same time as confucianism, taoism and legalism, and was one of the four main philosophic schools from around 770221 bc. During that time, mohism was seen as a major rival to confucianism.
Constitutional rights foundation bill of rights in action fall 2008 volume 24, no. The four books is a collection of confucian root texts. Confucianism deals with social matters, while taoism concerns itself with the search for meaning. These books are the book of history, the book of poetry, the book of changes, the book of rites, and the spring and autumn annals. The teachings of this school are found in the book mozi only recently partially recovered and it will be convenient for us to treat them as the teachings of mozi himself. We can add that confucianism offered a hierarchical social structure while mohism offered a collectivist, egalitarian view. Confucian books are boring if youre interested in holy stories, spiritual miracles, and afterlife thrills. Mozi taught the necessity for individual piety and submission to the will of heaven, or shangdi the lord on high.
Confucianism remained prevalent in china from the han dynasty in 202 bce to the end of dynastic rule in 1911. And shinto, distinctively japanese in character, is the most animistic of the great religions, based on a belief in numerous individual spirits. Variously described as tradition, a philosophy, a religion, a humanistic or rationalistic religion, a way of governing, or simply a way of life, confucianism developed from what was later called the hundred schools of thought from the teachings of the chinese philosopher confucius 551479 bce. The administrative thought of mohism was absorbed by chinese legalism and its books were later merged into the taoist canon, all but disappearing as an independent school of thought. Mohism, moism, mozi, mo tsu, utilitarianism, universal love. We know very little about most nonconfucian classical thinkers, and mozi is no. The four books sishu are chinese classic texts illustrating the core value and belief systems in confucianism. Laotzu was the legendary founder of daoism, recorded in the form of the book the tao te ching. Chinese philosophy refers to any of several schools of philosophical thought in the chinese tradition, including confucianism, taoism, legalism, buddhism and mohism see below for brief introductions to these schools. The expression of this indiscriminate caring is what makes man a righteous being in mohist thought. The three teachings taoism, buddhism, confucianism l. Mohism springs from the teachings of mo di, or mozi master mo, about whom little is known, not even what state he was from. But i really enjoyed studying confuciansm, mainly because. Im taking a comparative religions class this semester and have a test tomorrow.
Confucianism and taoism are both ancient chinese styles of living. Confucianism is humanism, a philosophy or attitude that is concerned with human beings, their achievements and interests, rather than with the abstract beings and problems of. Mohism or moism was an ancient chinese philosophy of logic, rational thought and science developed by the academic scholars who studied under the ancient chinese philosopher mozi and embodied in an eponymous book. Born a few years after confuciuss death, mozi was raised in a period. What is the structure of compare and contrast essay on taoism and confucianism. Taoism download books, sacred, spiritual texts and pdf e. I procrastinated and read all of each chapter today, about 50 pages on each, and studied for hours. According to yale university, the sacred texts of confucianism are five books that legend states confucius wrote. Many will find immediately objectionable van nordens characterization of neo confucianism as confucianism seen through buddhist lenses 316. Mozi taught the necessity for individual piety and submission to the will of heaven, or shangdi the lord on high, and. Their holy book is called the analects they study this book and tells them what.
Mohist books were later merged into the taoist canon. Yangs principle of each one for himself amounts to making one s sovereign of no account. Confucius didnt buy their ideas either, stating that mohists would let a. You could say that they were the first hippies because they loved everyone. Mohism is a philosophy that came into existence alongside confucianism, and has some similar concepts. The confucians, or ru, were just one of several widely recognized social or ethical movements, and the figures and texts we now call daoist did not represent an organized school or movement at all, but only a loose network of mentors and pupils with a roughly overlapping doctrinal orientation. Each philosophy had its own set of rules of how people should act both in public and privately. This philosophy challenged the dominant confucian ideology until about the 3rd century bce. What are the similarities between confucian and mohist conception of love. Confucianism daoism mohism legalism different and same free. Nov 22, 2016 confucian texts the lunyu analects are the most revered sacred scripture in the confucian tradition. The founder of confucianism was a man named kongzi, or master kong.
The three teachings taoism, buddhism and confucianism have been a backbone of chinese society and culture since the bronze age. The basis of mohism is universal love, which is similar to the belief of western christianity. There are thousands of classic textbooks of confucianism, none of them being holy. Records of the grand historian, the biographies of the moneymakers, in mao tao, confucian thought on the free economy, in the history of ancient chinese economic thought, ed. And honestly, of the several religions ive studied this far, christianity seems like a complete joke. Daoism advocated that the individual should follow a mysterious force, called the way dao, of the universe, and that all things were one.
1337 965 1067 140 1204 1019 104 1250 1312 391 157 765 1285 1053 871 563 1128 1247 1364 1601 1323 329 887 530 473 551 1107 244 1285 104 1318 642 1488